Response to Matt
With all due respect, you talk about history as if you think you know it.
I volunteer that there is no revelation implied from the Trumbo film as there is little difference in the ruthless self-interest of men of means and their politicians of the 21st c from the 20th to the 19th c except a more efficient media.
Today as yesterday, conservatives and corporations (in the 20th c) rule America with the power of money and those without it, fight among themselves and cannot begin to overcome this social imbalance of wealth and inequality without leaders like Lincoln or TR or FDR or MLK or even Lyndon Johnson (by default).
But the purpose of my comment, gentlemen, was to point out that the premise of the Trumbo film is derived from lies, innuendo and misinformation.
I do not judge the fine performance of the actors in this make-believe film, but I take exception that there is some value or substantive message learned from untold truth and the manipulation of facts.
Thanks for writing, Leroy, though (to misquote Sam Cooke) apparently you don't know much about reading comprehension. Nowhere do I state that Trumbo was a "hero"; in fact, I state that he was not a "saint" and was a "hypocrite."
One doesn't have to find Trumbo a hero to recognize that what was going on during this period was horrific, tragic, and a national disgrace. Of course, if you DO agree with what was being done by HUAC et al, then the stateside terrorists have already won.
And, uh, the fact that he was an unrepentant Stalinist. Only much later in life did he remotely show remorse and even then haltingly. Holodomor anyone?
The fact this reviewer refuses to acknowledge this man, talented though he was, as an apologist for massive atrocities, rather as a hero...well. As Sam Cooke sang, "Don't know much about history."
your Victor Frankenstein is interesting Harvey raved about it said it was a must see Joe
The movie Trumbo completely misrepresents the avarice conniving man that Trumbo was, he was all about the money and getting attention, he was not a hero, just a grandstander who took from others if he could get away with it.
So how about the truth and getting the facts right about Trumbo.
Fact – Trumbo was a fast writer and during the Blacklist period he was forced to write and rewrite scripts for less money for low-life producers like the King Bros and anyone else who paid him under the table. Trumbo did it for the money. The King Bros’s nephew Robert Rich, who was listed as the author, was an office errand boy and bag man who picked up scripts and delivered cash to pay Trumbo.
Fact - Roman Holiday may be Trumbo’s story for all I know, but he was not in Italy during the shooting of the film where most of the script was re-written by Director Billy Wyler and screenwriter Ian Hunter. They wrote script on set day to day and the nights before shooting the film, as was Wyler’s method of film making. Ian Hunter’s son would not return the Oscar when asked by the Academy to do so in order that the Academy issue Trumbo the Oscar decades later.
Fact - Dalton Trumbo lied about being the original author of the 1956 Oscar winning film, “The Brave One”. My father wrote the original screenplay.
Fact – “The Brave One” script marked “#1” with 170 pages is archived in the University of Wisconsin Library where Trumbo donated all his work. The “#1” script’s Title page was removed and no author was mentioned.
Fact - The “first version” (133 pages) and “second version” (119 pages) of the scripts listed “Screenplay by: Arthur J. Henley”.
Fact - The last two scripts listed “Screenplay by Merrill G. White and Harry S Franklin, Based on an Original Story by Robert L. Rich”.
Fact – When the King Bros listed their nephew Robert Rich as author they had no idea that “The Brave One” would be nominated for the Oscar for Best Original Story.
Fact - Robert Rich did not attend the Oscar awards because he was cooperating with the FBI who were watching Trumbo and he didn’t want to be publicly humiliated when the truth came out (FBI File Number: 100-1338754; Serial: 1118; Part: 13 of 15).
Fact - White and Franklin were editors and acting as shills for Trumbo before and after “The Brave One” movie. The King Bros did not initially intend that their nephew Robert Rich be a front for Trumbo. White and/or Franklin were fronts for Trumbo. It was only after the media played up the no-show at the Oscars that the King Bros and Trumbo saw this as a way to sell tickets and Trumbo could play the media as well as he wrote.
Fact – My Spanish father, Juan Duval, was a member of the Writer’s Guild of America (West). The WGAW destroyed my father’s original screenplays, which I’m told was the practice of WGAW.
Fact - Juan Duval, poet, dancer, choreographer, composer and director of stage and film, wrote the original story/screenplay that The Brave One was based and presented it to a shareholder in the King Bros production company, who then gave it to Morrie King (one of the three King brothers). My father died before film production began.
Trumbo re-wrote the screenplay and removed 50+ pages from the original script, some of which, was about the Catholic ritual of blessing the bulls before a bull fight.
If you read the screenplay marked #1 and the redacted letters in Trumbo’s book, “Additional Dialogue, Letters of Dalton Trumbo, 1942-1962” and compare them to the rewritten scripts and un-redacted letters archived at the University of Wisconsin Library, it’s obvious that Trumbo didn’t write the original screenplay, otherwise, why would he criticize and complain to the King Bros in so many letters about the original screenplay.
My father was born in Barcelona, Spain in 1897, he matriculated from the Monastery at Monserrat and moved to Paris in 1913, where he was renowned as a Classical Spanish and Apache dancer. In 1915, he was conscripted into the French Army and fought in Tunis and then at Verdun, where he was partially gassed and suffered head wounds. He joined the US Army after WWI and was stationed in occupied Germany for 2 years before immigrating to the US where he set-up a Flamenco dance studio in Hollywood, CA. My father worked in film and stage productions, and choreographed at least one sword fighting scene with Rudolf Valentino and made movies in Mexico and Cuba.
In 1935, my father directed the highest grossing Spanish speaking movie up to that time, which starred Movita (Marlon Brandon's second wife). My father's best friend was Federico Garcia Lorca and he tried to talk Lorca out of re-entering Spain in July 1936. In 1937, my father published a series of articles about the presence of Nazis in the Canary Islands and in one of the articles, he named who murdered Lorca and why.
My father joined the US Army Air Force in January 1942 and was sent to Tunis where he had fought in WWI. He was fluent in five languages and served as a Tech Sargent. He was Honorably Discharged for ill health in 1943, the same year that Trumbo joined the Communist Party.
Mizi Trumbo refused to talk to me about The Brave One original screenplay.
If Trumbo posthumously received the Oscar for the Roman Holiday story, then my father’s original story which the movie “The Brave One” was based certainly deserves to be recognized by Hollywood and the Academy of Arts and Sciences and posthumously awarded the Oscar for “Best Original Story”.
Before former Director of the Academy of Arts and Sciences Bruce Davis retired, he told me that because of the documentation that I provided him, he was inclined to believe that my father wrote the original screenplay which the movie, “The Brave One” was based.
I request that the Academy recognize my father’s work and issue him an Oscar for his original story and screenplay which the 1956 movie, “The Brave One” was based.
Comment by John Hart Duval
Personally, to me In Cold Blood is one of the best films ever made.
This is another racist movie where fat ugly Seth Rogen plays an explicitly Jewish character, while good-looking Jewish actors (Joseph Gordon-Levitt and Lizzy Caplan, this time) play non-Jews. As a matter of fact, despite being the son of two Jewish parents, Gordon-Levitt has never explicitly played his own ethnicity once in his entire 30 years of acting. Is there a problem, Joey?
This is the same racist trick Rogen pulls every time. He always casts himself as an explicit Jewish character opposite non-Jewish characters played by good-looking Jews (Paul Rudd, James Franco, Dave Franco, Zac Efron, Halston Sage, etc.).
And this new film is from the same studio, S.S.ony, that released last year’s Fury, about fighting Nazis during WWII. Fury starred no less than four Jews (Logan Lerman, Jon Bernthal, Jason Isaacs, and Shia LaBeouf), yet none of the characters were Jewish and Jews and the Holocaust were never mentioned. Gee, maybe they should have cast Seth Rogen as a “funny” Jewish soldier who died early on in the film.
Actors of fully Jewish background: Logan Lerman, Natalie Portman, Joseph Gordon-Levitt, Mila Kunis, Bar Refaeli, James Wolk, Jennifer Jason Leigh, Julian Morris, Adam Brody, Esti Ginzburg, Kat Dennings, Gabriel Macht, Erin Heatherton, Odeya Rush, Anton Yelchin, Paul Rudd, Scott Mechlowicz, Lisa Kudrow, Lizzy Caplan, Emmanuelle Chriqui, Gal Gadot, Debra Messing, Robert Kazinsky, Melanie Laurent, Shiri Appleby, Justin Bartha, Sarah Michelle Gellar, Margarita Levieva, Elizabeth Berkley, Halston Sage, Seth Gabel, Corey Stoll, Mia Kirshner, Alden Ehrenreich, Eric Balfour, Jason Isaacs, Jon Bernthal, William Shatner, Leonard Nimoy.
Andrew Garfield and Aaron Taylor-Johnson are Jewish, too (though I don’t know if both of their parents are).
Actors with Jewish mothers and non-Jewish fathers: Jake Gyllenhaal, Dave Franco, James Franco, Scarlett Johansson, Daniel Day-Lewis, Daniel Radcliffe, Alison Brie, Eva Green, Joaquin Phoenix, River Phoenix, Emmy Rossum, Rashida Jones, Jennifer Connelly, Sofia Black D’Elia, Nora Arnezeder, Goldie Hawn, Ginnifer Goodwin, Amanda Peet, Eric Dane, Jeremy Jordan, Joel Kinnaman, Ben Barnes, Patricia Arquette, Kyra Sedgwick, Dave Annable, Ryan Potter.
Actors with Jewish fathers and non-Jewish mothers, who themselves were either raised as Jews and/or identify as Jews: Ezra Miller, Gwyneth Paltrow, Alexa Davalos, Nat Wolff, Nicola Peltz, James Maslow, Josh Bowman, Winona Ryder, Michael Douglas, Ben Foster, Jamie Lee Curtis, Nikki Reed, Zac Efron, Jonathan Keltz, Paul Newman.
Oh, and Ansel Elgort’s father is Jewish, though I don’t know how Ansel was raised. Robert Downey, Jr. and Sean Penn were also born to Jewish fathers and non-Jewish mothers. Armie Hammer and Chris Pine are part Jewish.
Actors with one Jewish-born parent and one parent who converted to Judaism: Dianna Agron, Sara Paxton (whose father converted, not her mother), Alicia Silverstone, Jamie-Lynn Sigler.
Far too much switching back and fourth and I found myself looking at Michael Kelly and Dean Norris's toupees to see if a scene was in the past or present. That said, I'm not sure this film could have been made any differently.
Victims of pedophile priest crimes are still trying to get out our stories and expose aiding and abetting by church leaders, which happened all over the country. We face amazing obstacles. The story in Spotlight would never break if it was coming up in today's corporate media. For more true stories about these crimes and the survivors, please read City of Angels Blog by Kay Ebeling. Thank you. http://cityofangels12.blogspot.com/2013/07/pedophile-priest-true-crime-series.html
I was a huge Michael Landon fan when he did Bonanza. I loathed little House.... Nellie and Harriett Oleson were the only two interesting characters... Landon's huge ego was imprinted on every frame of the series.
Thanks for writing, BondFan. As noted in both the article and an above comment, that list is in chronological order; otherwise, Tracy would have been #1. And M was admittedly a close miss.
How is M's death in Skyfall not listed. M, Vespar and Tracy should be 1-3.
Thanks for writing, JT's White Suit (aka Garth Vader, because, let's face it, you're not fooling anyone by cowardly posting under different pseudonyms). Your sophomoric comments are always welcome!
You have fallen for Rather and Mapes' false version of events. I followed the story at the time. The "truth" was that these fine folks tried to throw an election using a badly-sourced story and some documents that are known to be false now and were known to be unreliable at the time. And they were caught, not by anyone "spewing misogyny and racism", but by a bunch of amateur bloggers tracking down the clues in real time. As CBS now says, it was maybe the biggest embarrassment in their history.
Read up on the story; wikipedia has a good treatment.
>> the Internet spewing misogyny and racism at every turn
You know Brunson, sometimes someone is just a jerk. Take you, you're a white male. But a jerk. So if Obama's a jerk, he's a jerk, not a "black jerk".
You were dead on about Pan, until your last comment. Hook worse than Pan?! Not by a long shot. I've enjoyed Hook with my children and grandchildren, many times. I'll never get back the two hours wasted watching Pan.
Also, I thought Garrett Hedland's Hook was trying (miserably) to mimic Harrison Ford...but Indiana Jones, not Han Solo. And Princess Tiger Lily, dressed as Cher, was pretty awful too.
In 1999 CBS also burned "The Insider" for the way 60 MINUTES (mis)handled The RJ Reynolds tobacco story.. The story that destroyed their integrity, credibility... Painted Mike Wallace in a very bad light to... All came down to money.
Thanks for writing, Pat. Or maybe you have the worse [sic] taste of all time?
Seriously, these days I refrain from commenting usually, but Hook was incredible. You are possibly the worse critic of all time.
Just so you know, Spirited Away is *still* Japan's all-time top moneymaker by a large margin.
Womack Newspapers, Inc.
Powered by Foundation