Pin It
Submit to Reddit

Like Oil and Water 

East/West gap at center of new thriller

Midway through John Burdett's evocative new thriller, Bangkok 8, there is a deceptively innocuous culture clash between the narrator -- a Bangkok detective -- and the female FBI agent sent to help him solve the murder of a US Marine. What seems like a minor social gaffe -- the FBI agent devours some ice cream while cleaning her gun when it occurs -- actually punctuates the yawning chasm between East and West that lies at the heart of this novel."To eat alone is a sad and pathetic condition in my country," the Thai detective notes to himself, "evidence of social and emotional dispossession. To do so in front of another without offering to share is an obscenity and almost impossible for me to watch. I feel the blood draining from my face as she gulps down a miniature Everest."

"What's the matter," the agent asks, "you scared of guns?"

In this and scores of other deftly written, tragicomic scenes, Burdett meditates on the many differences that underlie East and West: food (exotic vs. bland) and sex ("the West tries to turn the act of sex into a religious experience," notes the detective, "when to us it is no more than scratching an itch"); police work (deduction vs. intuition) and corruption (open graft vs. hypocrisy); and philosophies of life ("No one escapes their own culture," the detective says. "A consumer society is a consumer society. It may start with washing machines and air conditioning, but sooner or later we consume each other. It's happening to us too. But the Buddha taught freedom from appetite.").

Not surprisingly for a book steeped in Buddhist paradoxes and Eastern enigmas, the labyrinthine plot almost plays second fiddle to the eccentric personalities that people the story (the murder takes place on the first page, as though Burdett were saying, "Now that that's out of the way. . .").

Chief among them is the narrator, Sonchai Jitpleecheep, the half-caste offspring of a mysterious US serviceman and a world-class Thai bar girl. His multicultural background is more than a narrative device (though Burdett's previous novel, The Last Six Million Seconds, featured a Hong Kong detective of Chinese and Irish descent); it's a symbol of the clashing cultures at war all around -- and within -- Sonchai.

The dichotomies abound: he has a criminal past, enjoys the local drugs and has a weakness for fine clothes. But as a practicing Buddhist, he successfully battles the corrupting temptations of graft and flesh -- including the gorgeous form of the smitten FBI agent. He's educated in a Western sense -- he's fluent in English and French -- as well as an Eastern one, communicating regularly with his dead partner (killed investigating the marine's death) and seeing people's past lives as clearly as their current ones.

The other principals are as well-drawn as Sonchai. His ultra-pragmatic mother is coming out of retirement to open a Viagra-based niche bar after greasing the palms of her son's bosses. Sonchai's direct superior is the prototypically corrupt Third World official with unsavory CIA ties, who nevertheless grudgingly admires his charge's incorruptibility and serves as his protector. Even the sworn enemy of Sonchai -- by virtue of the vendetta for his partner's life -- is the Yin to Sonchai's Yang.

The Westerners are as fleshed out, but don't fare as well; this is the East, after all. The FBI agent is particularly frustrated by the Eastern mindset, especially since her agency background is based exclusively on deductive reasoning, and Sonchai appears to be the one man immune to her charms. The brother of the dead marine, a former drug kingpin in New York, doesn't have any more success adapting than the FBI agent, but can admit when he's whipped thanks to his street smarts. And the worldly jade exporter and Orientalist proves that he's the farthest of all from what the Buddha called "enlightenment."

By the end of the novel the case hasn't so much been solved as it has simply evolved into another state, posing as many questions as it answered. The only trial that takes place is the ongoing one where West and East collide. Soon, Burdett and his narrator suggest, one culture will emerge victorious: either the West will learn to adapt to life's illogical course and adopt the Eastern mindset of acceptance, or the East will be overrun by the West's need to control everything.

"To be frank, nothing has changed since The Quiet American," says the exporter, giving a nod to Graham Greene's seminal East-meets-West-East-regrets-it novel. "When we finally destroy the whole world it will be with the very best of intentions."

Pin It
Submit to Reddit


Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Creative Loafing encourages a healthy discussion on its website from all sides of the conversation, but we reserve the right to delete any comments that detract from that. Violence, racism and personal attacks that go beyond the pale will not be tolerated.

Search Events
items in Creative Loafing Charlotte More in Creative Loafing Charlotte pool

© 2018 Womack Digital, LLC
Powered by Foundation