Pin It
Submit to Reddit

A grape by any other name might taste as sweet 

Vermentino. Nero d'Avola. Primitivo. Falanghina. Trebbiano. Grillo. Vernaccia. Chardonnay. If faced with these words on a wine label, which would you buy? Um, yea, it's a trick question since 99 percent of people would say, "chardonnay" -- the only one people know. The rest are Italian native grapes, cultivated and drunk for thousands of years. But this indigenous fruit remains as unknown and misunderstood as Italy's sacrosanct labeling system. So a few years ago, crafty wineries began planting French grapevines that appealed to the rich, thirsty masses. The problem is, they suck. Too often, chardonnay, pinot noir and merlot adorn Italian labels that don't befit a country that once ruled the world. My recent tastes make me wonder if this native Italian sellout makes sense?

I don't begrudge a winery generating cash but if something isn't made well, I can't acquiesce. Perhaps remaining true to their native grape varieties would produce a more authentic wine. And just because people don't know the grape names shouldn't affect import decisions. Remember back when you had your first pinot grigio? Perhaps you swigged it from a paper bag in the back of a car? You were hip and cool, and probably didn't pronounce it right the first time. Someone corrected you and pinot grigio has been your touted favorite wine ever since. But how did you learn about it? A friend? An advertisement? An article? Your knowledge of pinot grigio came from somewhere. So why didn't the other really delicious wines from Italy make headway in the public conscious like American Idol? It's tragic really because when made well, Italian native varieties taste magical.

Vermentino is a fresh, crisp alternative to sauvignon blanc, great paired with shellfish or salty cheese. Nero d'Avola, a red native to Sicily, has smooth tannins, luscious dark fruit and suave personality. Huge crowd pleaser, even for those who aren't big wine fans. Primitivo -- aka zinfandel in our parts -- has the same powerful fruit and flavors of red zinfandel without the huge alcohol found in Californian versions. But why should you care about this Italian travesty? These wines are cheap, most hovering under $15. And they're tasty, food-friendly and approachable. Not even Caesar can beat that.

Wine Reviews

Tenuta Rapitala 2008 Camporeale Nero d'Avola Sicilia (Italy) The 30-year-old Camporeale vineyard lies in the rolling hills on the island of Sicily. This lovely nero d'avola is awash with plum, strong-brewed tea and ripe blackberry. Supple tannins, medium-boy and enough acidity to pair with roasted meats. Delicious. Sw=1. 4.5 stars. $13.

Layer Cake 2007 Primitivo Puglia (Italy) Inventive Layer Cake winery sources grapes from all over the globe, creating juicy, fruit-forward wines. This one from the Puglia -- the heel of the boot -- has ripe blueberry and jammy black cherry mixed in with earthy tar and a port-like finish. Sw=3. 4 stars. $12.

Santadi "Villa Solais" 2006 Vermentino di Sardegna (Italy) Not the green, tart vermentino you may have experienced in the past. This one smells like seawater, then surprises you with Riesling-like diesel fuel, earthy minerality, honey and red apple with a soft, lemony finish. Sw=1. $12. 3 stars.

Worth skipping:

Tormaresca 2007 Chardonnay Puglia (Italy) Although the piddly price tag really made me want to like it, I couldn't. Too steely, very little fruit, lacking the lemon and tangerine often found in unoaked chardonnay. Disappointing. Sw= 1. $10. 2.5 stars.

San Giuseppe 2007 Pinot Noir Veneto (Italy) These guys make delicious pinot grigio but fall short on this pinot noir (also called pinot nero in Italy). Tastes like a weak, underripe cabernet sauvignon with too much acidity, too little fruit and a green pepper finish that only milk can erase. Sw=1. $13. 2 stars.

Sweetness (Sw) rating: 1-10. Star rating: 1-5. Reach Taylor at, on Twitter @tayloreason, on Facebook and on her web site,

Pin It
Submit to Reddit


Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Creative Loafing encourages a healthy discussion on its website from all sides of the conversation, but we reserve the right to delete any comments that detract from that. Violence, racism and personal attacks that go beyond the pale will not be tolerated.

Search Events
items in Creative Loafing Charlotte More in Creative Loafing Charlotte pool

© 2018 Womack Digital, LLC
Powered by Foundation